|
Title: Item Tier List Discussion Post by: RingRush on September 20, 2009, 04:21:43 AM Feel free to debate and discuss if you are bored. Tiers based on usefulness and accessability. v1.2 (still a lot that needs rearrangement) ~Top Tier~ Bombs Bomb Bag Bombchu Hookshot Master Sword ~High Tier~ Kokiri Sword Deku Shield Hover Boots Hylian Shield Light Arrows Cucco Bottle Ruto's Bottle Fishing Pole Quiver Broken Sword Bugs Deku Sticks Fairy Bow Mirror Shield Zelda's Lullaby Deku Nut Requiem of Spirit ~Medium Tier~ Fish Golden Scale Megaton Hammer Fire Arrows Boomerang Nayru's Love Poacher's Saw Cojiro Poe Scarecrow's Song Farore's Wind Din's Fire Heart Container Gold Skulltula Token Adult's Wallet Fairy Biggoron's Sword Goron Tunic Longshot Fairy Ocarina Serenade of Water Epona's Song Giant's Knife ~Low Tier~ Golden Gauntlets Fairy Slingshot Bullet Bag Ocarina of Time Song of Time Zora Tunic Minuet of Forest Bigger Bomb Bag Biggest Bomb Bag Odd Potion Bolero of Fire Bunny Hood Prelude of Light Odd Mushroom Iron Boots Giant's Wallet Blue Fire Zora Mask Lon Lon Bottle Magic Beans Goron Bracelet Lon Lon Milk Heart Piece Sun's Song Nocturne of Shadow Pocket Cucco Pocket Egg Eyeball Frog Prescription Eye Drops Claim Check Zelda's Letter Song of Storms Blue Potion ~Bottom Tier~ Silver Gauntlets Bigger Quiver Biggest Quiver Lens of Truth Big Poe Green Potion Ice Arrows Gerudo's Card Cucco Weird Egg Saria's Song Mask of Truth Goron Mask Gerudo Mask Skull Mask Spooky Mask Keaton Mask Bigger Bullet Bag Biggest Bullet Bag Red Potion ~Guay Tier~ Silver Scale Sinking Lure Stone of Agony Title: Re: Item Tier List Discussion Post by: chaosv1 on October 09, 2009, 11:54:31 PM Suggestions:
Light Arrows -> Top Tier Essential to beat the game, RBA or otherwise Golden Scale -> Same as Ruto Bottle That or the silver scale is required to get the ruto bottle, and who would ever get the silver scale ;) Blue Potion -> Bottom or Guay Tier Not so useful and even harder to get than red/green potions. I only ever got this when i had infinite money for the hell of it Red/Green Potion -> Guay Tier Absolutely useless. I never even bought this the first time I played OoT Title: Re: Item Tier List Discussion Post by: RingRush on October 10, 2009, 03:56:20 AM Moved all of those in the direction you stated, just not as far.
Light Arrows, while essential, simply aren't as versitile, useful, or easy to obtain as Hookshot or Hover Boots or Chus. Title: Re: Item Tier List Discussion Post by: Maxx on October 21, 2009, 12:16:35 AM Silver Gauntlets are way better than that. Easily mid-tier. Accessibility alone is huge, and Golden are barely more useful at all. The fact that kid Link can use them even though they won't fit a kid is also a huge boon.
I think Kokiri Sword could hit top tier, but that's arguable. Cojiro is a possible high tier candidate. At least one bottle needs to be top tier (likely Cucco, due to ease of accessibility). Bottle is the most versatile, powerful, and useful item in the game (Bombs/chus are pretty close, though). Megaton Hammer needs knocked down a bit. Accessibility is shoddy, usefulness is minimal. Zora Tunic is bottom tier, as it's completely useless even in most legit Water Temple playthroughs. Title: Re: Item Tier List Discussion Post by: Lexkeeta on October 21, 2009, 11:33:46 PM you forgot black/green/blue/bronze gauntlets
Title: Re: Item Tier List Discussion Post by: GlitchesAndStuff on October 25, 2009, 12:34:21 PM Farore's wind is used alot in 100% and although Nayru's love makes easy superslides and megaflips, it can all be done without it...
so I think Farore's wind should go one above Nayru's love... or atleast one below because I think it's a useful item... |